| Philip Lambrecht |
| d. March 14th, 1872 |
| Thomas J. Norton |
| d. December 18th, 1881 |
| John J. Carey |
| d. November 3rd, 1892 |
| Robert J. Thorpe |
| d. August 13th, 1900 |
| John J. Sheridan |
| d. July 16th, 1902 |
| Joseph Guarnieri |
| d. April 2nd, 1914 |
| John J. Quinn |
| d. February 16th, 1918 |
| James S. Maher |
| d. July 27th, 1919 |
| John E. Fitzpatrick |
| d. May 20th, 1920 |
| Joseph J. Bridgetts |
| d. February 17th, 1921 |
| William A. Miller |
| d. January 5th, 1922 |
| Francis J. M. Buckley |
| d. January 6th, 1922 |
| John J. Moriarty |
| d. July 2nd, 1922 |
| John T. Donohue |
| d. February 16th, 1923 |
| Francis P. Baker |
| d. April 22nd, 1923 |
| Bernardino Grottano |
| d. May 26th, 1924 |
| Timothy J. Connell |
| d. July 12th, 1924 |
| Chester A. Hagan |
| d. February 14th, 1925 |
| Richard M. Heneberry |
| d. August 6th, 1925 |
| John M. Singer |
| d. August 11th, 1926 |
| Morris Borkin |
| d. May 17th, 1927 |
| Thomas E. Hill |
| d. July 28th, 1930 |
| Harry D. Bloomfield |
| d. August 9th, 1930 |
| Christopher W. Scheuing |
| d. February 19th, 1931 |
| William H. DeGive |
| d. June 28th, 1931 |
| Guido J. Pessagno |
| d. October 22nd, 1931 |
| James J. Garvey |
| d. April 21st, 1934 |
| Michael J. Foley |
| d. April 10th, 1937 |
| Isadore Astel |
| d. August 11th, 1937 |
| Arthur DeMarrais |
| d. November 7th, 1937 |
| Ferdinand A. Socha |
| d. July 4th, 1940 |
| Joseph J. Lynch |
| d. July 4th, 1940 |
| Joseph A. Miccio |
| d. December 8th, 1942 |
| Anthony McGinley |
| d. December 27th, 1944 |
| Frank M. McGrath |
| d. September 27th, 1945 |
| James J. Burke |
| d. December 13th, 1946 |
| James L. Daggett |
| d. September 10th, 1951 |
| Philip A. LaMonica |
| d. September 21st, 1952 |
| William F. Christman |
| d. October 8th, 1956 |
| Francis X. O'Rourke |
| d. January 21st, 1958 |
| Philip J. Curtin |
| d. October 2nd, 1960 |
| John P. Finnegan |
| d. May 18th, 1962 |
| Luke J. Fallon |
| d. May 18th, 1962 |
| John F. Tobin |
| d. October 29th, 1962 |
| Richard D. Arundell |
| d. February 9th, 1963 |
| Donald Rolker |
| d. November 27th, 1963 |
| Joseph V. Greene |
| d. May 3rd, 1964 |
| James A. Donegan |
| d. October 15th, 1964 |
| Salvatore Potenza |
| d. October 15th, 1964 |
| Harold A. Jacob |
| d. January 18th, 1967 |
| John D. Pollins |
| d. March 14th, 1967 |
| Richard A. Rotanz |
| d. August 21st, 1968 |
| Clifton A. Eastby |
| d. December 30th, 1968 |
| John Roth |
| d. April 24th, 1969 |
| Joseph A. Picciano |
| d. February 15th, 1971 |
| Erle Thompson |
| d. February 20th, 1971 |
| Ivan I. Lorenzo |
| d. May 5th, 1971 |
| Harold Marshall |
| d. December 7th, 1971 |
| William R. Capers |
| d. April 3rd, 1972 |
| George Caccavale |
| d. June 26th, 1976 |
| Henry R. McDevitt |
| d. June 26th, 1977 |
| Joseph D. Taylor |
| d. August 29th, 1977 |
| Horace L. Ford |
| d. November 6th, 1978 |
| Abraham Walton |
| d. July 14th, 1980 |
| Anthony J. Venditti |
| d. January 21st, 1986 |
| Louis L. Miller |
| d. March 11th, 1987 |
| Joseph Galapo |
| d. August 16th, 1988 |
| Richard J. Guerzon |
| d. November 13th, 1989 |
| Keith L. Williams |
| d. November 13th, 1989 |
| William T. Gunn |
| d. November 27th, 1992 |
| Luis Lopez |
| d. March 10th, 1993 |
| Alfred Boesch |
| d. January 21st, 1995 |
| Kenny Fung |
| d. January 13th, 1997 |
| Sean Carrington |
| d. January 19th, 1998 |
| Claude Daniel Richards |
| d. September 11th, 2001 |
| Joseph V. Vigiano |
| d. September 11th, 2001 |
| Jaime Betancourt |
| d. March 31st, 2002 |
| Salvatore Cafiso |
| d. October 24th, 2002 |
| James V. Nemorin |
| d. March 10th, 2003 |
| Rodney J. Andrews |
| d. March 10th, 2003 |
| Patrick H. Rafferty |
| d. September 10th, 2004 |
| Robert Parker |
| d. September 10th, 2004 |
| Dillon Hugh Stewart |
| d. November 28th, 2005 |
| Daniel Enchautegui |
| d. December 10th, 2005 |
| James Zadroga |
| d. January 5th, 2006 |
| Sandra Y. Adrian |
| d. January 11th, 2006 |
| Roberto L. Rivera |
| d. January 27th, 2007 |
| John T. Young |
| d. February 17th, 2007 |
| Kevin G. Hawkins |
| d. May 7th, 2007 |
| Robert W. Williamson |
| d. May 13th, 2007 |
| Russel Timoshenko |
| d. July 14th, 2007 |
| William J. Holfester |
| d. January 22nd, 2008 |
| John E. Goggin |
| d. May 6th, 2008 |
| Omar J. Edwards |
| d. May 28th, 2009 |
| Michael P. Morales |
| d. June 10th, 2009 |
| Corey J. Diaz |
| d. October 7th, 2009 |
| Joseh E. Seabrook |
| d. May 29th, 2010 |
| Kevin A. Czartoryski |
| d. December 5th, 2010 |
| Edwin Ortiz |
| d. July 4th, 2011 |
| Peter J. Figoski |
| d. December 12th, 2011 |
| Alick Herrmann |
| d. December 23rd, 2011 |